# 3900
One of the subjects I’ve written about several times over the summer is that no matter how good a job the CDC and HHS do with this pandemic, they going to be criticized. They are in a no-win situation.
That’s something I wrote about in July in an essay called Hubris And The Flu, and before that in early May with Before We Ride Down And Shoot The Survivors.
It isn’t fair of course. But that’s the way it is. When you take on the job, you automatically get a target on your back.
Which is one of the reasons I try to temper my criticisms of these agencies. I’m at least partially aware of how difficult the task before them really is.
While there have been some communication missteps along the way, I find myself pretty impressed with the CDC’s response so far. Not perfect, of course. But nothing ever is.
Maggie Fox, Health and Science Editor of Reuters, takes a hard look at this no-win fight today.
U.S. government faces no-win fight with flu
Wed Oct 28, 2009 12:41pm EDT
By Maggie Fox, Health and Science Editor – AnalysisWASHINGTON (Reuters) - First came the jibes about the U.S. government rushing out an untested swine flu vaccine. Now, critics say it is not fast enough.
"The premise that 'you can't win' is part of the equation," said Dr. D.A. Henderson, who advised the administration of former president George W. Bush on pandemic preparedness.
It is a lesson playing out in real time by U.S. government health officials as the H1N1 pandemic turns from a scientific and logistical battle to a political one.
Related Post:
- Do1Thing: A 12 Step Preparedness Program
- CDC FluView Week 52
- CDC Statement On This Year’s Flu Activity
- CDC HAN Update On Fungal Meningitis Outbreak
- Referral: McKenna On The Steroid-Linked Meningitis Outbreak
- NIVW 2012
- Early Flu Cases Begin To Emerge
- MMWR: Yosemite Hantavirus
- CDC Update Of Fungal Meningitis Cases
- A Health Crisis In Slow Motion
- UK: Norovirus Season Starts Early
- MMWR: Carbon Monoxide Exposures Related To Hurricane Sandy
- Peru: Alert For Bubonic Plague In Ascope Region
- CDC HAN Advisory: Additional NECC Products Found Contaminated
- CDC: Laboratory Test Results From Meningitis Outbreak
- FDA Statement On Conditions Reported At NECC Facility
- CDC Fungal Meningitis Update – Oct. 26th
- Preparing For After The Storm Passes
- The UK’s Whooping Cough Outbreak
- CDC HAN Advisory & Updates On Fungal Meningitis
- CDC Fungal Meningitis Update – Oct 22nd
- CDC Fungal Meningitis Update – Oct 19th
- CDC Fungal Meningitis Update – Oct 18th
- Detailed Report On Fatal Meningitis Case
- CDC Fungal Meningitis Update – Oct 17th
- HHS: Call For Public Comment On H5N1 Research
- CDC Statement On OIG Report On Vaccine Program For Children
- IOM Report On Vaccine Safety Concerns
- HHS Facebook Programming Challenge
- HHS Proposal To Improve Human Medical Research
- CDC Grand Rounds Webcast: Electronic Health Records
- Video: H5N1 – The Next Pandemic?
- Promising Practices & Pandemic Toolkits
- HHS Webcast Today: Pregnant Women And Flu
- Influenza Social Media Toolkits
- 2010 Flu Season: A Look Ahead
- Two From CIDRAP
- HHS Unveils Emergency Medical Countermeasures Report
- The Amazing Growth Of New Media
- PHE.GOV: Public Health Preparedness Has A New Home
- Pandemic And Preparedness Video Roundup
- AHRQ Report: Little Progress Seen On HAIs
- HHS `New Media’ Interview Today
- HHS Video: We Heard The Bells
- An Open Letter To The American People On The Flu Vaccine
- National Influenza Vaccination Week
- IOM: Priorities For The National Vaccine Plan
- HHS To Review Vaccine & Public Health Response Policies
- Thanksgiving Is National Family History Day
- HHS Webcast Monday
Widget by [ Iptek-4u ]