Photo Credit CDC PHIL
# 5988
Over the past couple of weeks bird flu researchers have been slammed repeatedly in the popular press for conducting experiments that have produced a better H5N1 virus.
One that is not only lethal, but transmits well among mammals. (see New Scientist: Five Easy Mutations)
Many media pundits have seized the populist high ground on this issue by calling these researchers `mad scientists’ and by evoking visions of bioterrorists making up vials of this (admittedly) nasty pathogen in their basement.
It’s not hard to demonize a person, a project, or an idea . . . if you know how.
Use the right `buzz’ words, ridicule or defame a person or their goals – no matter how worthy - and in short order complex issues become one-sided affairs.
Soon nearly everyone is on the bandwagon, and very quickly any opposing views are marginalized.
Of course, things are rarely as simple, or one-sided, as many people would have you believe (see The Bird Flu Research Debate Continues).
While there are legitimate issues over how much detail of these experiments should end up published, the actual research is important if we are to understand the evolution (and true threat) of the H5N1 virus.
Carl Zimmer is a well known author (12 books & counting) and science writer, who among other things, pens The Loom blog on Discover Magazine.
Today he explains why this research matters, and how little these scientists actually had to do to facilitate the creation of this lethal strain.
Very much worth reading. Follow the link to read:
Making viruses the natural way
Related Post:
- Health Vigilance For The Chinese New Years
- Indonesia: H5N1 Clade 2.3.2 Reaches Bali
- H5N1 in 2012: The Year in Review
- Egypt: A Paltry Poultry Vaccine
- CIDRAP News Coverage Of The H5N1 NIH Workshop
- Watching Indonesia Again
- WHO: H5N1 Update
- Hong Kong: H5N1 Vaccine Recommended For Certain Lab Workers
- Indonesia MOH Reports Bird Flu Fatality
- VOA Report On The Indonesian Duck Die Off
- Dr. Alan Hampson Interview On Indonesia’s New Bird Flu Clade
- Report: Clade 2.3.2 H5N1 Detected In Indonesia
- India: The H5N1 & Migratory Birds Debate
- Bangalore: More Poultry Culled Due To H5N1
- HHS: Call For Public Comment On H5N1 Research
- Nepal: H5N1 Outbreak In Poultry
- mBio: Should The H5N1 Research Moratorium End?
- Vietnam Reports Progress On New Bird Flu Vaccine
- Vietnam: Ministry Bans Transport Of Waterfowl Over H5N1 Fears
- China Reports H5N1 Outbreak In Poultry
- Watching Egypt
- V Said, C Said
- Vietnam Intensifies Bird Flu Prevention Efforts
- Indonesia Announces H5N1 Fatality
- EID Journal: Persistence Of H5N1 In Soil
- Branswell On Lifting The H5N1 Research Moratorium
- The Return Of The Hygiene Hypothesis
- NIH: News From The Human Microbiome Project
- More Reaction To The Kawaoka Paper
- Nature Publishes The Kawaoka H5N1 Study
- Reminder: National Academies Webcast Today On H5N1 Research
- National Academies Webcast On H5N1 Research: May 1st
- Dutch Govt. Grants Fouchier Export License For H5N1 Research
- Fouchier Research To be Debated In The Netherlands This Week
- Royal Society H5N1 Symposium: Day 2
- Webcast: Royal Society Meeting on H5N1 Research
- The Scientist: Deliberating H5N1 Research
- NSABB Clears H5N1 Studies For Publication
- U.S. Issues New DURC Oversight Rules
- NSABB To Re-examine H5N1 Research Risks
- Dysfunctional Science
- Luck Of The Draw
- Peter Sandman On Talking To The Public About H5N1 Risks
- Laurie Garrett Dissects The Rationale For H5N1 Research
- Branswell: WHO Hopes H5N1 Studies Can Be Published By Summer
- The H5N1 Research Credibility Gap
- Science Magazine: NSABB Members React To Fouchier Statement
- ECDC Risk Assessment On H5N1 Transmissibility Studies
- Peter Doherty On H5N1 Research
- Lancet: Increasing Incidence Of Infectious Diseases In New Zealand
- Branswell On Flu Vaccine Matches
- Referral: McKenna On MRSA In UK Milk
- Referral: McKenna On The Steroid-Linked Meningitis Outbreak
- Referral: CIDRAP News Summarizes The Coronavirus Story
- Referral: McKenna On The NEJM Coronavirus Report
- Maryn McKenna Video On Disease, Cities, and Our Crowded Future
- Referral: McKenna On Pertussis Vaccines
- Referral: Ed Yong On Poultry Vaccine Recombination
- Referral: McKenna On Resistant UTIs
- Researchers Discover New Flu Gene
- Referral: McKenna Times Four
- Laurie Garrett: Risks Of FMD & Bird Flu Destabilizing Egypt
- Four Million Fears, BC
- Laurie Garrett Blogs On The H5N1 Research Controversy
- Referral: McKenna On India’s Denial Of TDR-TB
- Referral: Crof On Cholera
- Referral: A Summary Of Worldwide H5N1 Cases in 2011
- Referral: Maryn McKenna On Regulatory Obstacles To Fecal Transplants
- Nature: Special Influenza Supplement
- Referral: McKenna On NDM-1 In India
- Referral: Maryn McKenna On The Listeria Outbreak
- New Scientist: Five Easy Mutations
- SciAm: What Will The Next Influenza Pandemic Look Like?
- Maryn McKenna On The Science of Contagion
Widget by [ Iptek-4u ]