# 4252
Last night CIDRAP News ran a well sourced piece co-written by Lisa Schnirring and News Editor Robert Roos, which gives voice to a number of well respected and internationally known flu experts who refute the charges being levied against the World Health Organization that this has been a `false pandemic’.
Among those whose opinions appear in this article are Dr David Salisbury (head of the United Kingdom's immunization program), Australia's chief medical officer Dr Jim Bishop, British Health Secretary Andy Burnham, and Walter R. Dowdle, MD, former deputy director of the CDC.
The heavy lifting, however, comes from interviews of Dr. Gregory Poland, MD, Director of the Vaccine Research Group at the Mayo Clinic, and CIDRAP Director Michael T. Osterholm.
An excerpt, but follow the link to read the whole thing.
Health officials, experts reject 'false pandemic' charges
Lisa Schnirring and Robert Roos
Staff Writers
Jan 13, 2010 (CIDRAP News) – Leading public health officials and experts have sharply rejected charges from some European officials that pharmaceutical companies used exaggerated claims about the H1N1 pandemic threat to scare governments into buying unnecessary stockpiles of vaccines.
The Council of Europe, an organization of 47 nations, said yesterday that the charges will be on the agenda when its Parliamentary Assembly meets in Strasbourg, France, later this month. The assembly's Social Affairs Committee has asked for a debate on the theme "False pandemics: a threat to health," according to a statement on the council's Web site.
The charges, detailed in a proposed resolution, come as the United Kingdom, France, Germany, and other countries are scaling back their vaccine orders. Weak demand for the vaccine in the face of declining flu activity and the need for just one dose have left many countries with surpluses, though public health officials warn that another wave of infections could come this winter.
Dr Wolfgang Wodarg, a German physician and politician who chairs the Council of Europe's health committee, was quoted in the British media as saying the World Health Organization's (WHO's) pandemic declaration last June triggered vaccine contracts with governments and that companies reap financial benefits without taking any risks. He told the London Daily Mail that the pandemic H1N1 virus was "a mild flu and a false pandemic."
Related Post:
- Pakistan To Resume Polio Vaccinations
- CIDRAP News Coverage Of The H5N1 NIH Workshop
- Public Health Practices (PHP) Update
- Referral: CIDRAP News Summarizes The Coronavirus Story
- Peter Sandman On the CCIVI Vaccine Report
- CIDRAP: The Need For `Game Changing’ Flu Vaccines
- CDC Telebriefing on West Nile Virus
- CDC: Updated H3N2v Surveillance & Testing Guidance
- EID Journal: Flu In Healthy-Looking Pigs
- CIDRAP: Children & Middle-Aged Most Susceptible To H3N2v
- Mexico: High Path H7 In Jalisco
- Updating Public Health Practices (PHP)
- TEDx UMN: Rethinking Influenza Vaccines
- CIDRAP News: NSABB May Revisit H5N1 Research
- CIDRAP: Exploring the CFR Of H5N1
- The Tamiflu Controversy Continues
- CIDRAP: H5N1 Transmissibility in Ferrets vs Humans
- CIDRAP News: Signs Of Tamiflu Resistant H1N1 Spreading
- Two New Swine trH3N2 Studies To Ponder
- Public Health Practices Update
- Developing A trH3N2 Seed Vaccine
- CIDRAP: New Details In The trH3N2 Story
- CIDRAP: A Comprehensive Flu Vaccine Effectiveness Meta-Analysis
- CIDRAP: Conflicting Theories On the 1918 Pandemic
- CIDRAP On Today’s Reassorted Swine Flu Story
- EID Book Review - Spillover: Animal Infections and the Next Human Pandemic
- Study: Self-Administered Vaccines In Adults
- BMC: Exploring The `Age Shift’ Of Pandemic Mortality
- WHO Europe: Revising Pandemic Preparedness Plans
- Paper: Are We Prepared For A Pandemic In Low Resource Communities?
- CSIRO: The Quest For Flu Resistant Poultry
- University of Michigan: Influenza Encyclopedia 1918-1919
- Lancet: Public Response To The H1N1 Pandemic Of 2009
- Pathogens At the Gate
- NIAID Video: How Influenza Pandemics Occur
- IDSA: Pandemic and Seasonal Influenza Preparedness
- An Increasingly Complex Flu Field
- Study: Kids, Underlying Conditions, And The 2009 Pandemic Flu
- Hong Kong Updates Their Pandemic Preparedness Plan
- Yes, We Have No Pandemic . . .
- Study: Antimicrobial Prescribing Practices During The 2009 Pandemic
- Novel Viruses & Chekhov’s Gun
- MIT: Contagion Dynamics Of International Air Travel
- Pandemic Uncertainties
- Lancet: Estimating Global 2009 Pandemic Mortality
- PNAS: H1N1 Vaccination Produced Antibodies Against Multiple Flu Strains
- Lancet: David Fedson On Statins For Pandemic Influenza
- H5N1: Now That They’ve Broken The `Species Barrier’
- Downton Abbey Rekindles An Old HCW Debate
- Study: The Effects Of School Closures During A Pandemic
- Hong Kong’s Coronavirus Response
- NWS: Possible Coastal Storm Mid-Week
- Caveat Twitter
- Bulletin Of The Atomic Scientists: Fukushima Crisis in review
- WHO Panel: World Ill-Prepared To Deal With A Pandemic
- Brookings Institute: A Year Of Living Dangerously
- Japan: OCHA SITREP # 4
- IAEA: Onagawa Facility Declares Level 1 Emergency
- IAEA Update On Fukushima Plant Explosion
- IHR Review Committee Report On The Pandemic Of 2009
- PHAC: Lessons Learned From The 2009 Pandemic
- PLoS Essay: Reflections On The International Pandemic Response
- Two From CIDRAP
- ASEAN-UN-USAID Pandemic Response Exercise
- Dr. David Fedson: The Case For Using Statins In A Pandemic
- IRIN Analysis: Egypt’s Response To The Pandemic
- WHO Europe Chief Interview
- John Barry On The Pandemic Response
- HPA Conference: Pandemic Lessons Learned
- Pandemic Briefing Note 21: WHO Responds To Critics
- The CDC’s Oil Spill Response Page
- Margaret Chan’s Open Letter To The BMJ
- WHO Confirms China H5N1 Fatality, Rejects BMJ Report
- Referral: New Scientist On The WHO `Conspiracy’
- Of Pandemics, Hurricanes and An Abundance Of Caution
Widget by [ Iptek-4u ]